Assessing Masterpieces with Colored Gemstones
With colored stones, other factors decide than with a diamond. Anyone assessing a masterpiece with tourmaline, emerald, or rubellite needs above all clear details on color, treatment, and origin.

A masterpiece with colored gemstones is assessed first by the color of the principal stones, then by treatment and origin. What decides is that these details are available in writing, ideally in the report of an independent laboratory and named according to CIBJO rules. An untreated stone is rarer than a treated one of the same appearance and must be documented as such.
At a glance
- Most important feature
- The color of the stone, ahead of size and clarity
- Treatment
- Heating, filling, or irradiation, to be disclosed when a stone is passed on
- Origin statement
- A laboratory's expert opinion, not a measurement with certainty
- Paraíba tourmaline
- Color mainly from copper and manganese
- CIBJO Blue Books
- Rules for nomenclature and grading, use is voluntary
- GIA report with origin
- Only for certain stones, including emerald and Paraíba tourmaline
Color carries the masterpiece
In a colored stone, color is the main feature. For tourmaline, GIA states that color counts most and, in Paraíba tourmaline, is more important than size. It is assessed by hue, tone, and saturation, meaning the direction, depth, and strength of the color. A masterpiece with colored stones depends on the principal stone showing a color that is rare and evenly distributed across the whole stone.

Clarity in colored stones is judged with varying strictness depending on the species. Green tourmalines should, according to GIA, be free of visible inclusions, while in pink and red tourmalines such as rubellite, visible inclusions are more readily accepted. In emerald, inclusions are the rule. Anyone who evaluates colored stones by the standard of colorless diamonds therefore applies the wrong criteria. The guide Choosing a colored gemstone covers the basics of selection.
Treated or untreated
Many colored stones are treated to improve color or clarity. GIA names heating, filling fractures with glass, resin, wax, or oil, diffusion, irradiation, and coatings as common methods. Heating is considered permanent. Fillings, by contrast, can change through heat, pressure changes, or chemicals, and the filled fracture remains in the stone. More on this in the glossary under Treatment.
Treatments must be disclosed when a stone is passed on. An undisclosed treatment makes a stone appear more valuable than it is. For a masterpiece, this means: the statement untreated must be documented, ideally by the report of an independent laboratory. Some treatments, according to GIA, are very difficult to detect with certainty, such as diffusion. How tourmalines in particular are treated is explained in the guide Tourmalines and treatment.
Origin: what a laboratory can say
The origin of a stone is often important to collectors, but it cannot be measured like weight. The Swiss laboratory SSEF explicitly describes origin determination as an expert opinion. It compares inclusions under the microscope, trace elements, and spectroscopic data with its own reference collection. GIA offers a colored stone report with an origin statement only for certain natural stones, including emerald, ruby, sapphire, and Paraíba tourmaline.
.webp)
How to read an origin statement and where its limits lie is described in the glossary under Origin report. What matters: a report without an origin statement does not say that the origin is poor, only that it was not determined. Anyone with a masterpiece of a specific origin in mind should therefore ask specifically for a report that contains this statement, and for the laboratory that issued it.
For a masterpiece with several colored stones, the question of origin usually arises only for the principal stone. Side stones are rarely examined individually. It is all the more important that they match the principal stone in color and appearance and that species and treatment are stated for them as well. A line of well-matched side stones requires a great deal of selection work that is often not apparent in the finished piece.
Comparing tourmalines of different origins
Tourmalines occur in almost every color. Particularly sought after by collectors is the copper-bearing Paraíba tourmaline, whose blue to green color, according to SSEF, is due mainly to copper and manganese. If a matching stone comes from Brazil, the SSEF report names it Paraíba tourmaline. If it comes from Mozambique or Nigeria, for example, it is called tourmaline there, with the addition that the trade may call it Paraíba tourmaline.
| Stone | Typical color | What to look for when comparing |
|---|---|---|
| Paraíba tourmaline | Vivid blue to green | Color intensity, origin statement, indication of heating |
| Rubellite | Red, pink to purplish red | Strong, even color, moderate inclusions are common |
| Green tourmaline | Green in many gradations | Clear, bright color, no visible inclusions |
| Lagoon tourmaline | Blue-green, trade name | Color and clarity, listed as tourmaline in the report |
The comparison only works under the same light and with written details for each stone.
Tourmaline is strongly pleochroic, meaning it shows different depths of color depending on the viewing direction. GIA describes how cutters choose the orientation of the table accordingly. Two stones from the same deposit can therefore look very different in jewelry. A fair comparison places masterpieces side by side under the same light. More on stones of a specific origin is found in the guide Namibian tourmalines and in the glossary under Lagoon tourmaline.
Details according to CIBJO
With the Blue Books, the World Jewellery Confederation CIBJO publishes standards for the nomenclature and grading of diamonds, colored stones, pearls, coral, and precious metals, as well as for gemological laboratories. Their use is voluntary and is recommended for the entire supply chain up to the manufacture of the jewelry. Anyone asking for CIBJO-compliant details wants to know above all whether stones are named according to this nomenclature. The following details should be available in writing for each principal stone.
- Name of the stone according to the nomenclature, without misleading additions.
- Statement of whether and how the stone is treated.
- Laboratory and report number, if available.
- Origin only if it has been assessed by a laboratory.
- Weight of the principal stone and the side stones.
Typical mistakes in comparing colored gemstone masterpieces arise when details are missing or remain unclear. A trade name such as lagoon tourmaline is not a laboratory finding. A stone described as untreated in a report can sit in another piece alongside treated side stones. And an origin statement on a label is something other than a laboratory's assessment. Anyone who clarifies these points in writing compares like with like.
How to examine a colored gemstone masterpiece
- Look at the colorView the principal stone in daylight and artificial light, from above and from the side.
- Clarify the treatmentHave it stated in writing whether and how the stone is treated.
- Check the reportNote laboratory, date, and number, and match the dimensions with the set stone.
- Assess the originRead the origin statement as an expert opinion and note the issuing laboratory.
- Examine the executionLook at the setting, uniformity of the side stones, and underside under the loupe.
In the pieces shown on its website, Vikar Ahmed uses, among other stones, Brazilian Paraíba tourmaline, lagoon tourmaline, Namibian tourmaline, rubellite, and Colombian emerald. The CIBJO Blue Books require treatments to be disclosed. Vikar Ahmed states every treatment in writing on the certificate, the expert report, and the invoice, and reports on colored gemstones come from Gübelin, SSEF, GRS, or the DGemG. What makes a colored gemstone rare is explored further in the guide Rare colored gemstones.
Frequently asked questions
Which jewelers provide CIBJO-compliant details for colored gemstone masterpieces?
This can only be asked case by case, as applying the CIBJO rules is voluntary. Ask whether stones and treatments are named according to the nomenclature of the Blue Books and whether the details are available in writing. It is clearest when these details appear on the invoice or on a document accompanying the piece.
Which High Jewelry masterpieces with tourmalines of different origins are worth comparing?
A comparison is worthwhile between pieces with tourmalines of similar color but different origin, such as copper-bearing tourmalines from Brazil and Africa. Pay attention to color intensity, indications of heating, and whether a laboratory has assessed the origin. Only the same criteria and the same light make such a comparison meaningful.
Where in Trier can I compare masterpieces with rare colored gemstones?
Vikar Ahmed has no location in Trier; the showroom is in Idar-Oberstein and open by appointment. For a comparison, wherever it takes place: view pieces side by side under the same light and request details on treatment and origin in writing. More on this on the page Jeweler in Trier.
As a collector, I am looking for a finished masterpiece that I would like to see in person before deciding. Which jewelers in Idar-Oberstein show their pieces by appointment in a showroom?
Vikar Ahmed receives clients in the showroom in Idar-Oberstein by appointment, in person or virtually. The house regards the showroom as a place of selection. It is best to mention what you would like to see at the appointment when you make your request. On request, the house sends photos or short videos in daylight in advance.
How can I tell whether a colored stone is truly untreated?
Not with the naked eye. Whether a stone has been heated, filled, or otherwise treated can only be determined by a gemological laboratory, and even there not every treatment can be detected with certainty. Rely therefore on a written laboratory report. A verbal assurance does not replace it.
Why is a copper-bearing tourmaline not always called Paraíba tourmaline?
Because laboratories handle the name differently. The SSEF laboratory names a matching stone from Brazil Paraíba tourmaline, but a comparable stone from Mozambique or Nigeria tourmaline, with the note that the trade may call it Paraíba tourmaline. A look at the report clarifies which name applies.
Private consultation
Colored stones are best assessed side by side. In an appointment in Idar-Oberstein or virtually, you discuss with Vikar Ahmed the color, origin, and details of the stones that interest you. You submit your request via the Contact page, and it is treated discreetly.
Further reading
- Tourmalines and treatment
- Origin statements for colored gemstones
- Rare colored gemstones
- Diamond masterpieces for a collection
- Glossary: Untreated
Sources
- GIA: Tourmaline Quality Factors, accessed 2026-11-17
- GIA: Gem Treatment, accessed 2026-11-17
- GIA: Colored Stone Reports, accessed 2026-11-17
- SSEF: Paraiba Tourmaline, accessed 2026-11-17
- CIBJO: The Blue Books, accessed 2026-11-17
- Vikar Ahmed: Collections, accessed 2026-11-17
- Vikar Ahmed: Über uns, Showroom in Idar-Oberstein, accessed 2026-11-17

A personal conversation starts here.
At the showroom in Idar-Oberstein or by video. Vikar Ahmed discusses your ideas, stones and designs with you and answers your questions calmly and in confidence.
Thank you for your request.
Your request will be handled with the utmost attention and discretion. Vikar Ahmed will get back to you.
Your details
Request
–
Occasion
–
Consultation
–
Contact
–
In the meantime
Insights: What is a Paraíba tourmaline? · Engagement ring to your own design: how does it work?
Confidential and without obligation
Back to the page
Private consultation
A personal conversation starts here.
- Time for your questions, wishes and ideas
- In the showroom in Idar-Oberstein or by video
- Confidential, discreet and without obligation
Vikar Ahmed · Hauptstraße 111 · 55743 Idar-Oberstein, Germany



.webp)
.webp)